Matthew S. Kilgo, MD, FACS
Matthew S. Kilgo, MD, FACS
Secretary: Ashley, p: (516) 629-3866 f: (516) 393-4432
Dr. Matthew S. Kilgo, MD, FACS, is a board-certified plastic surgeon and partner at New York Plastic Surgical Group, where he has practiced since 2005, serving patients throughout New York City and Long Island. With more than 25 years of clinical and surgical experience, he specializes in cosmetic breast surgery and body contouring, with particular interest in complex and revisional cosmetic breast procedures. Known for his technical precision, thoughtful clinical judgment, and compassionate approach to care, Dr. Kilgo provides individualized surgical solutions across the full spectrum of cosmetic breast and body contouring.
In addition to his clinical work, he is an accomplished educator and researcher whose work has been presented at national and international surgical conferences, and he maintains active surgical privileges at leading hospitals across the New York metropolitan area. His excellence has been consistently recognized by Castle Connolly Medical Ltd as a “Top Doctor in the NY Metro Area” since 2014, an honor awarded to physicians nominated by their peers and ranked among the top 10–15% in their specialty, and he has also been included on the “Best Doctors in America” list based on surveys of more than 45,000 U.S. physicians. More recently, he has been named to Newsweek’s list of America’s Best Plastic Surgeons since 2022 for breast augmentation, with additional recognition in 2024 for excellence in liposuction.
Follow Dr. Kilgo
Meet Dr. Matthew S. Kilgo
Dr. Matthew S. Kilgo, MD, FACS, is a board-certified plastic surgeon and partner at New York Plastic Surgical Group, where he has practiced since 2005, serving patients throughout New York City and Long Island. With more than 25 years of clinical and surgical experience, Dr. Kilgo specializes in cosmetic breast surgery and body contouring, with particular interest in complex and revisional breast procedures. Known for his technical precision, thoughtful clinical judgment, and compassionate approach to care, he provides individualized surgical solutions across the full spectrum of plastic and reconstructive surgery.
An accomplished educator and researcher, Dr. Kilgo’s work has been presented at national and international surgical conferences, and he maintains active surgical privileges at leading hospitals across the New York metropolitan area. His excellence has been consistently recognized by Castle Connolly Medical Ltd as a “Top Doctor in the NY Metro Area” since 2014, and he has been included on the “Best Doctors in America” list based on surveys of more than 45,000 U.S. physicians. More recently, he has been named to Newsweek’s list of America’s Best Plastic Surgeons since 2022 for breast augmentation, with additional recognition in 2024 for excellence in liposuction.
Education
Undergraduate Education
Dr. Kilgo earned his Bachelor of Science in Biology from Loyola University of Chicago (1986–1989), graduating Summa Cum Laude. His rigorous academic foundation in the biological sciences prepared him for advanced medical training and a career dedicated to surgical excellence.
Medical School
Dr. Kilgo earned his Doctor of Medicine from the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine in Chicago, Illinois (1989–1993). His medical school training provided comprehensive instruction in clinical medicine, surgical principles, and patient care.
Residency Training
Following medical school, Dr. Kilgo completed a comprehensive General Surgery Residency at the University of Wisconsin Hospitals and Clinics in Madison, Wisconsin (1993–1997), under the direction of Layton Rikkers, M.D., FACS, Chairman.
Fellowship Training
Dr. Kilgo completed advanced fellowship training in two specialized areas of plastic surgery:
- Plastic Surgery Fellowship at Indiana University School of Medicine in Indianapolis, Indiana (1999–2001), under the direction of John J. Coleman, III, M.D., Chairman
- Microsurgery and Breast Fellowship at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York, New York (2001–2002), under the direction of Peter Cordeiro, M.D., Division Chief
Additionally, Dr. Kilgo completed a Visiting Fellowship as Senior Registrar in Breast and Vascular Surgery at Gloucestershire Royal Hospital in Gloucester, England (1998–1999), providing international training in advanced breast surgical techniques and reconstructive approaches.
Board Certification and Professional Credentials
Dr. Kilgo is board-certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (certified November 2003, Diplomat #6575) and holds the distinction of Fellow of the American College of Surgeons (FACS). He is also a Diplomat of the American Board of Surgery (certified May 1999, #44050) and the National Board of Medical Examiners (certified May 1994, #432772). Board certification and fellowship status demonstrate that Dr. Kilgo has met rigorous standards of knowledge, clinical competency, and ethical practice—and maintains ongoing commitment to professional excellence through continuing education and recertification.
Professional Affiliations and Memberships
Dr. Kilgo maintains active membership in leading professional organizations dedicated to advancing plastic surgery:
- American Society of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (ASPRS): The leading professional organization of plastic surgeons certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery who specialize in cosmetic and reconstructive surgery
- The Aesthetic Society: A prestigious professional organization of board-certified plastic surgeons dedicated to advancing the art and science of aesthetic surgery through education, research, and patient safety standards.
- American College of Surgeons (ACS): A prestigious organization dedicated to improving the quality of care for surgical patients through education, advocacy, and professional standards
- Nassau Surgical Society: A regional surgical organization promoting surgical excellence and peer education
- Northeastern Society of Plastic Surgeons: A regional professional organization of board-certified plastic surgeons
- New York Regional Society of Plastic Surgeons: A regional professional organization that fosters collaboration, continuing education, and the advancement of plastic surgery standards among surgeons throughout the New York area
These memberships reflect Dr. Kilgo’s dedication to staying current with the latest advances in plastic surgery and maintaining the highest standards of clinical practice.
Clinical Experience and Areas of Expertise
25+ Years of Plastic Surgery Practice
Dr. Kilgo has spent over two and a half decades providing comprehensive cosmetic and reconstructive surgery to patients throughout New York City and Long Island. His clinical experience encompasses:
Breast Surgery:
- Breast augmentation
- Breast lift
- Breast reduction
- Breast revision and secondary procedures
- Breast reconstruction (autologous and implant-based techniques)
Body Contouring:
- Abdominoplasty (tummy tuck)
- Body lift and contouring procedures
- Liposuction and fat grafting
- Body contouring after massive weight loss
Advanced Surgical Techniques and Innovation
Dr. Kilgo has extensive expertise in advanced surgical techniques, including:
- Preservé breast augmentation
- Auto-augmentation techniques in breast and body contouring
- Use of the “internal bra” technique with bio-absorbable mesh in breast surgery
- High-definition liposuction
His refined surgical technique and high case volume reflect both patient trust and his commitment to achieving consistent, excellent outcomes in one of plastic surgery’s most demanding specialties.
Dr. Kilgo has completed advanced training in the Preservé™ Breast Augmentation Method, a tissue-conscious approach that emphasizes meticulous planning, refined technique, and the preservation of natural breast structures when clinically appropriate. This method utilizes specialized instrumentation to support smaller incisions, minimized tissue disruption, and stable implant positioning, with the goal of achieving natural-looking, balanced results.
Dr. Kilgo selectively incorporates Preservé principles based on each patient’s anatomy and goals, reflecting his commitment to thoughtful innovation and modern surgical options in breast augmentation.
Surgical Volume and Expertise
With more than 25 years in practice, Dr. Kilgo has performed over 8, 000 surgical procedures, the majority of which involve breast and body surgery, reflecting the depth and breadth of his surgical experience.
His extensive surgical volume supports a refined, patient-specific approach to treatment planning, technical execution, and long-term outcomes. Managing both routine and highly complex cases has strengthened his expertise in tailoring surgical strategies to each patient’s anatomy, diagnosis, and aesthetic goals.
Research, Education, and Academic Contributions
Dr. Kilgo is an active researcher and educator with multiple peer-reviewed publications in leading plastic surgery journals. His research focuses on breast reconstruction outcomes, oncoplastic surgery, surgical innovation, and optimization of reconstructive techniques.
Published Peer-Reviewed Articles:
- Kilgo, MS, Kaufman, G, Shen, A, Korsh, J, Douglas, B, Brewer, B. “A Comparison of Elliptical Mastectomy to Inverted-T Pattern Mastectomy in Two Stage Prosthetic Breast Reconstruction.” Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 136(4):426e-433e, October 2015.
- Simpson, AM, Higdon, KK, Kilgo, MS, Tepper, DG, Glat, PM, Alizadeh, K, Agarwal, JP. “Porcine acellular peritoneal matrix in immediate breast reconstruction: a multicenter prospective single-arm trial.” Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, January 2019.
- Aliano, KA, Agulnick, M, Cohen, B, Gonya, G, Low, C, Stavrides, S, Addona, T, Goncalves, J, Shin, D, Kilgo, MD, Davenport, TA. “Spinal reconstruction for osteomyelitis with free vascularized fibular grafts using intra-abdominal recipient vessels: A series of three cases.” Microsurgery, October 2013.
- Kilgo, MS, Howard, MA, Kaplan, G, Rabbani, F, Scardino, PT, Cordeiro, PG. “Evaluation of Genitofemoral Nerve Donor Site Morbidity After Radical Prostatectomy.” Annals of Plastic Surgery, 55(1): 57-62, July 2005.
- Kilgo, MS, Cordeiro, PG, Disa, JJ. “Tissue Expansion after ‘Inverted T’ Mammaplasty: Can It Be Done Successfully?” Annals of Plastic Surgery, 50(6): 588-93, 2003.
- Eppley, BL, Kilgo, MS, Coleman, JJ. “Cranial Reconstruction with Computer Generated HTR Patient Matched Implants: Indications, Surgical Technique, and Long-Term Follow-up.” Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 109(3): 864-71, 2002.
- Kilgo, MS, Pirsch, JD, Warner, TF, Starling, JR. “Tertiary Hyperparathyroidism After Renal Transplantation: Surgical Strategy.” Surgery, 124(4): 677-83, 1998.
Textbook Contributions:
Kilgo, MD, Coleman, J. “Reconstruction of the Burned Scalp.” Chapter 9 in Achauer and Sood’s Burn Surgery, Reconstruction and Rehabilitation. Elsevier Health Sciences, May 2006.
Conference Presentations and Educational Leadership:
Dr. Kilgo’s work has been presented extensively at national and international conferences.
- American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) Annual Meeting
- American Society for Reconstructive Microsurgery (ASRM) Annual Meeting
- American College of Surgeons Clinical Congress
- Northeastern Society of Plastic Surgeons
- Nassau Surgical Society
- NYU-Winthrop Medical Oncology Grand Rounds
- Breast Cancer Summit (multiple years: 2013, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2023, 2024)
His presentations cover topics including implant-based breast reconstruction, pre-pectoral reconstruction techniques, oncoplastic surgery, body contouring after massive weight loss, and advanced microsurgical reconstruction. Dr. Kilgo has also served as a panel speaker and educator at community and patient education events, including Breast Awareness Month lectures and bariatric support group presentations.
Professional Recognition and Honors
Dr. Kilgo has received numerous accolades recognizing his surgical expertise and commitment to patient care:
National Recognition:
- Newsweek’s List of America’s Best Plastic Surgeons – Recognized for Breast Augmentation (2022, 2023, 2024, 2025) and Liposuction (2024)
- New York Times Super Doctors (2020, 2021)
- Best Doctors in America® – Elected by his peers for inclusion in Plastic Surgery (2011–2014)
Regional Recognition:
- Castle Connolly Top Doctor – Recognized in the New York Metro Area (2014–2026)
- Long Island Press – Named one of the Best Cosmetic Surgeons (2012)
Patient Recognition:
- Patients’ Choice and Most Compassionate Doctor Recognition – Vitals (2011–2013)
- Academic Recognition:
Best Research Presentation Award – Annual Meeting of the Wisconsin Surgical Society (1997)
Hospital Appointments and Leadership
Dr. Kilgo maintains active surgical privileges at three major regional medical centers, reflecting his standing within the medical community and his commitment to providing high-quality surgical care:
- NYU Langone Long Island, Mineola, NY (since April 2005)
- Mercy Medical Center, Rockville Center, NY (since April 2005)
- St. Francis Hospital, Roslyn, NY (since January 2011)
Patient Care Philosophy
Dr. Kilgo believes that exceptional plastic surgery results begin with understanding each patient’s unique goals, concerns, and aesthetic preferences. His approach emphasizes:
Personalized Surgical Planning: Rather than recommending a one-size-fits-all approach, Dr. Kilgo takes time to listen carefully to each patient’s concerns, perform thorough clinical assessment, and develop a customized surgical plan that aligns with their individual goals, body proportions, and lifestyle.
Transparent Communication: Dr. Kilgo prioritizes honest, detailed discussions about treatment options, realistic outcome expectations, potential risks and benefits, and recovery timelines. He believes informed patients make better decisions about their care.
Natural-Looking Results: Dr. Kilgo’s surgical philosophy emphasizes achieving results that look natural, proportionate, and harmonious with each patient’s overall appearance—not overdone or obviously “surgical.”
Comprehensive Care: From initial consultation through post-operative follow-up, Dr. Kilgo and his team provide attentive, coordinated care to ensure patient comfort, safety, and satisfaction.
Commitment to Excellence: Dr. Kilgo maintains rigorous standards of surgical technique, patient safety, and clinical outcomes through ongoing education, research, and collaboration with colleagues.
Patient Feedback
Frequently Asked Questions About Dr. Kilgo
What are Dr. Kilgo’s credentials and qualifications?
Dr. Kilgo is board-certified by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (certified 2003) and holds the distinction of Fellow of the American College of Surgeons (FACS). He earned his MD from the University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine and completed his plastic surgery residency at Indiana University School of Medicine, followed by a fellowship in microsurgery and breast surgery at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. He is also a Diplomat of the American Board of Surgery.
How much experience does Dr. Kilgo have?
Dr. Kilgo has over 25 years of clinical and surgical experience in plastic surgery. He has completed extensive training in all aspects of cosmetic and reconstructive surgery, with particular expertise in cosmetic breast and body contouring surgery.
What procedures does Dr. Kilgo perform?
Dr. Kilgo specializes in breast augmentation, breast reduction, abdominoplasty, body contouring after massive weight loss, and fat grafting.
Is Dr. Kilgo involved in research or education?
Yes. Dr. Kilgo is an active researcher with multiple peer-reviewed publications in leading plastic surgery journals. His research focuses on breast reconstruction outcomes, oncoplastic surgery, and surgical innovation. He has presented extensively at national and international conferences and maintains active involvement in surgical education through grand rounds, tumor boards, and educational symposia.
What is Dr. Kilgo’s approach to patient care?
Dr. Kilgo believes in personalized surgical planning, transparent communication, and achieving natural-looking results that align with each patient’s unique goals. He emphasizes informed decision-making, comprehensive pre- and post-operative care, and rigorous surgical standards.
How do I schedule a consultation with Dr. Kilgo?
To schedule a consultation, contact Dr. Kilgo’s office at (516) 742-3404. Our team will help you schedule an appointment at a time that works for your schedule. Dr. Kilgo is currently seeing patients at our Garden City location and maintains surgical privileges at Winthrop University Hospital, Mercy Medical Center, and St. Francis Hospital.
About New York Plastic Surgical Group
New York Plastic Surgical Group (NYPS Group), the Manhattan division of Long Island Plastic Surgical Group, offers comprehensive cosmetic and reconstructive surgical care for patients across Long Island and New York City. The practice blends decades of clinical experience with advanced surgical technology and a highly personalized approach to care.
With more than 340,000 procedures performed, the New York Plastic Group has built a longstanding reputation for clinical excellence, academic involvement, and ongoing innovation within the field of plastic surgery. The group’s expertise has been recognized by major national and regional media outlets, including The New York Times, CNN, CBS, NBC, Newsday, and the Discovery Channel.
Book Online
*Virtual Consultations available, please select Virtual Visit Type.
- Manhattan
- Long Island
- Brooklyn
- Queens
- Westchester
- Connecticut
- New Jersey
